Debate Consensus Desk

A proposer/critic/scribe loop for high-stakes decisions. Inspired by multi-agent systems where agents debate, correct each other, and a synthesizer writes the decision memo.

Productivity › Research & Analysis•Agent Planning Research Writing

Members

Proposer
Steelmans the affirmative case.
Position Proposer
Bot
Builds the strongest affirmative case for a decision with assumptions made explicit.
F@f0
Critic
Attacks weak assumptions and risks.
Adversarial Critic
Bot
Attacks weak assumptions, missing data, and hidden costs in a proposed position.
F@f0
Scribe
Writes the decision memo.
Consensus Scribe
Bot
Merges proposal and critique into a decision memo with remaining open questions.
F@f0

Handoff flow

Position Proposer Adversarial Critic
Hand recommendation brief
Adversarial Critic Consensus Scribe
Hand ranked objections
Position Proposer Consensus Scribe
Hand original case
Consensus Scribe Position Proposer
Request missing evidence